10/14/09

Birthday / Event

by billmurry

My wife and I had lobster last night celebrating my birthday. We have been to Mcgraths for the past three years on birthdays, anniversary etc. We ordered the lobster tail from the fall festival special, which the price was five dollars cheaper then the regular price. The salad was good, the potato was cool with sour cream only. This is not what we ordered, the lobster had no flavor, it was rubbery and it was the same for both dinners. I had to tell a few co-workers that was wanting to go, to reconsider.

05/07/09

Bad Experience

by goodbyemrjones

A friend and I ate at Mcgrath's Fish House. We ordered fish that was floating in gobs of butter. My friend would

not let me send food back. We ate and left. 2 hours later at my hotel, I had diarear for several hours. The food was supposed to be fresh. It was really disgusting.

I contacted manager at restaurant. He said he would call me back but never did. Beware!!

I would never eat at this restaurant again.

• Pros: Atmosphere
• Cons: No fresh fish

12/09/08

We LOVED it!.

by itsu526

McGrath's is pretty expensive by my standards but I stil plan to go back. I thought it was great and my bf really enjoyed his meal as well. I don't normally like seafood and frequently order fried fish in order to avoid getting something that is too strongly fishy for me but I didn't wus out this time. I got pecan encrusted sole and just loved it.

• Pros: fresh, delicious fish
• Cons: the bread was lousy, had a strange off taste

10/11/08

First time

by hokage

The service was friendly and helpful with picking out something. She knew what she liked which helps with explaining the menu. The vegetables were my favorite part of this meal. They were delicious and not salted or buttered, but had a flavor of seasonings that made them perfect. The fish was grilled and bland. Just an average restaurant.

• Pros: Good Service
• Cons: Typical

07/07/08

A Perfect Sunday Afternoon

by salon7000

It had been a few years since going to this resturaunt. My last experience just wasn't all that great. Well yesterday they completely redeemed themselves. Service was above and beyond perfect. The drinks were wonderful, the food was fresh and tasty. I enjoy good food as long as the package is complete with service also. This was a complete full package. Highly recommend this place.

• Pros: Great food, ambience, excellent service, prices
• Cons: nothing

02/07/08

Don't bother...

by Mikes1234

Had eaten here several times before 2007, better than average seafood at least by AZ standards. Last time in 2007, my mother had a big family gathering and the food was completely awful. Our party would have been happier eating Long John's Silver for the same price. Never again. Makes Red Lobster look like a 5 star.

• Pros: Air Condition in Summer
• Cons: everything else

11/22/06

Above average meals and atmosphere

by santefoss

This restaurant is more of a home cooked seafood restaurant. Nothing flashy, not big on sauces, just good quality, fresh fish, McGrath's has great maritime decorations, and adequate service. They don't have a specific item they're known for. Portions are kind of small, but overall it is a good dining experience.

• Pros: Fresh, home cooked style seafood
• Cons: Occasionally gets busy.

Editorial Review by Marlene Montanez

by Contributor

Appetites are welcome at this seafood restaurant favorite where there are big portions and a casual vibe.