We have tried NYPD Pizza quite a few times now and love it. The pizza has great flavor with ample topping and choices. We have tried both the Sicilian (thick crust) and the original crust. Always a struggle to pick a favorite. A word of warning is the Sicilian style will fill you up with one piece though!
Definitely, the Brooklyn is ordered almost every time. The pizza is not to heavy with toppings and there is just enough cheese. We have brought others to the restaurant, they have all loved it.