McGraths Fish House

10/14/09

Birthday / Event

by billmurry at Citysearch

My wife and I had lobster last night celebrating my birthday. We have been to Mcgraths for the past three years on birthdays, anniversary etc. We ordered the lobster tail from the fall festival special, which the price was five dollars cheaper then the regular price. The salad was good, the potato was cool with sour cream only. This is not what we ordered, the lobster had no flavor, it was rubbery and it was the same for both dinners. I had to tell a few co-workers that was wanting to go, to reconsider.

05/07/09

Bad Experience

by goodbyemrjones at Citysearch

A friend and I ate at Mcgrath's Fish House. We ordered fish that was floating in gobs of butter. My friend would

not let me send food back. We ate and left. 2 hours later at my hotel, I had diarear for several hours. The food was supposed to be fresh. It was really disgusting.

I contacted manager at restaurant. He said he would call me back but never did. Beware!!

I would never eat at this restaurant again.

• Pros: Atmosphere
• Cons: No fresh fish

12/09/08

We LOVED it!.

by itsu526 at Citysearch

McGrath's is pretty expensive by my standards but I stil plan to go back. I thought it was great and my bf really enjoyed his meal as well. I don't normally like seafood and frequently order fried fish in order to avoid getting something that is too strongly fishy for me but I didn't wus out this time. I got pecan encrusted sole and just loved it.

• Pros: fresh, delicious fish
• Cons: the bread was lousy, had a strange off taste